A different set of eyes

Digg
Lindsey Caldwell, Maynard Intern
May 4, 2009

Lindsey CaldwellRecently, after talking to several different peers of mine I was once again reminded of how one's ethnicity, upbringing and surrounding environment can result in people having different perspectives on the same situation. For example, when Oscar Grant was shot and killed in front of hundreds of citizens at the Fruitvale Bart Station in Oakland there was only one thought racing through my head: another example of racially motivated police brutality. However, as the days passed and my peers and I were able to have discussions about Grant's killing I found that everyone didn't share my opinion. In fact, when I first started talking to a peer (who happened to be Caucasian) about what had happened the first thing that she said was that Grant must have done something to provoke the police man who shot and killed Grant. It seemed ludicrous to me that anyone would even say that statement aloud, but it reminded me that there are so many different ways to look at the same situation.

In contrast, while I was talking to a peer who happens to be an ethnic minority, he had the same reaction to the killing as I did. In our opinion, unless Grant was using a lethal weapon to assault another person, there was no need for this police officer to even use his weapon. It appears that Grant, who was not armed, was fully compliant with the officer's demands. After discussing this incident again with the first peer, she became open to the idea that there was a high chance that this was a racially motivated shooting committed by an authority figure whose job is to protect all people - people just like Oscar Grant.


After hearing and digesting some of the comments made by my peers about the Oscar Grant case, I know that these prejudices come from a lifetime of media portraying African-American citizens in a light that is rarely positive. When I asked the woman who had automatically assumed that Grant had committed some wrong doing to be shot why she had assumed this, she came to the conclusion that it was because usually in the news these incidents are shown to be caused by something other than racial motivations. Meaning, what she takes away from the news is that, more often than, not incidents similar to this are caused by some action the victim took.

This is a perfect example of how dangerous the media can be when it spreads messages with underlying prejudice, racism or bias. My generation has grown up in a time when these biases are still the norm, and not many people are asking for a new perspective.

The discussions I held with my peers over the murder of Oscar Grant sparked long term frustration that I believe was partly caused by the misrepresentation of certain minority groups in the media. In my opinion, this is completely unfair but, luckily, completely changeable.

It is up to us as a society to make the changes that will result in a national shift of thinking. We have succeeded as a country in selecting a candidate for presidency who is a catalyst for change not just from the Bush administration, but for our societal behaviors and attitudes as well. Becoming aware of the problem our media faces today is the first step in working towards change.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
4 + 7 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Download the Oakland Tribune Community Journalism Project's Community Correspondent Form.
JOIN OUR BLOG DISCUSSION
Come join Sally Lehrman, a professor and journalist who writes regularly on race, gender and identity issues and Maynard Institute President Dori J. Maynard as we talk about the best and worst of media coverage and diversity. Add comments and give us your thoughts.

BLACK HISTORY MONTH
The Maynard Institute gears up for its coming celebration of Black History Month

Much of today's media coverage breaks the country into black and white, North and South, male and female. Doing so fails to capture the complexity of American life that journalists need to portray.

Based on the late Robert C. Maynard's belief that the five fault lines of race, class, gender, generation and geography are the most enduring forces shaping lives, experiences and social tensions in this country, the Maynard Institute's Fault Lines framework helps journalists build a more diverse source list, have more voices in stories and determine which fault lines are at work in complex issues.
[more...]
Black History Project
Stories of the African American journalists who broke into media during the '60s and '70s.
Caldwell Journals
An account of the pioneers who broke the color barrier in America's newspapers
Ed Bradley
View video from his interview as part of the Black Journalists Movement Project

Black History Month and Beyond documents and preserves the stories of those courageous African American journalists who broke into general circulation media during the turbulent 1960s and 1970s. [more...]

Martin Reynolds
View an interview with Martin Reynolds, Managing Editor at the Oakland Tribune.
Media Academy
View video from the Maynard Media Academy at Harvard University
Chauncey Bailey
View video and more from the Chauncey Bailey Project
History Project
Stories of the African American journalists who broke into media during the '60s and '70s.
Caldwell Journals
An account of the pioneers who broke the color barrier in America's newspapers
Ed Bradley
View video from his interview as part of the Black Journalists Movement Project