ASNE Report
Digg

Originally appeared:

Sally Lehrman, Shauna Scott Rhone
April 24, 2009

 

A sickly ecosystem that lacks diversity cannot survive


By Sally Lehrman

In the natural world, a population with nearly identical individuals is destined for doom. All too easily, too much rain, a warming trend, a new predator, or any challenge can wipe everyone out. Whether in the sea, sky, forest or desert, adaptation relies on difference.

That's why I think that the only newspapers still alive and flourishing ten years from today will be the ones that have staffs at leastas diverse as the communities they serve. They may be national or hyperlocal, all online or delivered on thin-film sheets that double as photovoltaic panels,who knows? For certain, though, they will be nimble. The Asian American, black, American Indian, Latino and white women and men in their newsrooms will form a web of talent and resources that allow speedy change under pressure.

Click here to read Sally's post.

 

The price of parity


By Shauna Scott Rhone

According to the American Society of Newsroom Editors’ annual report, American daily newspapers pink-slipped 5,900 newsroom employees in 2008. Of those shown the door, 854 were minorities. At least, that’s the total among the newspapers that responded to the survey.

Who knew a lack of color could mean darkness? But the decrease of journalists of color in American newsrooms and bureaus around the world not only makes the paper’s voice paler. It also dims the light of sunshine shone by those word scribes and image sculptors who rose from the neighborhoods of their darker brothers. In fact, that sunshine burned my desire to become a journalist deep into my heart years ago.

Click here to read Shauna's post.

 

Sad irony

The irony is that your essay is just inches away from the words of the newspaper executive quoted in Dori Maynard's piece who said that: "Diversity isn't only off the front-burner, it's not even in the kitchen." I fear that in the short term, newspaper execs will prefer to seek salvation in metrics and page views equations rather than taking a hard look at the importance of newsroom diversity.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
6 + 0 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.

Download the Oakland Tribune Community Journalism Project's Community Correspondent Form.
JOIN OUR BLOG DISCUSSION
Come join Sally Lehrman, a professor and journalist who writes regularly on race, gender and identity issues and Maynard Institute President Dori J. Maynard as we talk about the best and worst of media coverage and diversity. Add comments and give us your thoughts.

BLACK HISTORY MONTH
The Maynard Institute gears up for its coming celebration of Black History Month

Much of today's media coverage breaks the country into black and white, North and South, male and female. Doing so fails to capture the complexity of American life that journalists need to portray.

Based on the late Robert C. Maynard's belief that the five fault lines of race, class, gender, generation and geography are the most enduring forces shaping lives, experiences and social tensions in this country, the Maynard Institute's Fault Lines framework helps journalists build a more diverse source list, have more voices in stories and determine which fault lines are at work in complex issues.
[more...]
Black History Project
Stories of the African American journalists who broke into media during the '60s and '70s.
Caldwell Journals
An account of the pioneers who broke the color barrier in America's newspapers
Ed Bradley
View video from his interview as part of the Black Journalists Movement Project

Black History Month and Beyond documents and preserves the stories of those courageous African American journalists who broke into general circulation media during the turbulent 1960s and 1970s. [more...]

Martin Reynolds
View an interview with Martin Reynolds, Managing Editor at the Oakland Tribune.
Media Academy
View video from the Maynard Media Academy at Harvard University
Chauncey Bailey
View video and more from the Chauncey Bailey Project
History Project
Stories of the African American journalists who broke into media during the '60s and '70s.
Caldwell Journals
An account of the pioneers who broke the color barrier in America's newspapers
Ed Bradley
View video from his interview as part of the Black Journalists Movement Project